Have you ever built up an author (or director, musician,
etc.) in your head as being one of the greats? Maybe even a genius in their
respective field? Now I don’t think David Gemmell is a genius, but I’ve always
considered him a skilled writer who excels at certain types of stories. Those
stories often focus on tough men put in situations where their survival is in
question but the situation often leads to their redemption as heroes for having
done the honourable thing in said difficult situation. I’ve pointed out his
weaknesses as a writer before (female characters!) and his stories can be
similar when looking at them side by side (yet they’re usually varied enough in
the details to remain separate individual works). Sometimes he plays with big
ideas and when he does, he rivals many of the other great fantasy authors. To
be clear, I think David Gemmell is pretty great and up until a few weeks ago,
at least, he was one of my favourite fantasy authors, comfortably sitting
amongst the other greats in the literary pantheon of my mind.
Oh, how the mighty have fallen.