Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix - Reread Review (Mario)

I used to think that Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix was one of my favourite books in the series, but after rereading the fifth book really have to disagree with myself. It’s a good book, most definitely, but the more complex Rowling’s universe becomes, the more there are inconsistencies and small plot holes. That’s in addition to how the story also starts to feel bloated. I’m not sure how to feel about it. When I was rereading the fourth book, I knew going in that I had issues with some of the plot points, but I didn’t recall having issues with this book. Really though, what upsets me the most is just how fucking annoying Harry is. He’s fifteen and whinier than ever. I just want to sit him down and have an intervention. Dumbledore also acts rather irresponsibly. Maybe I should have a sit down with him too. Really though, that’s the most frustrating thing about this book: how some members of the regular cast seem to have lost their marbles or are just incredibly annoying. Many of the new characters, despite their short appearances, really flesh out the world of Harry Potter and leave a lasting impression. It’s in great part because of the new characters and the explosiveness of Rowling’s continuous world building that makes Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix a memorable read, despite its flaws.

Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix - Reread Review (Myriam)

I think it is safe to say we have now passed the half-way point. I must admit it is bitter-sweet seeing as I am absolutely loving the experience! Alright, I hope I’m up for tackling book 5, I took many notes while reading, as not to forget any blog-worthy details.

So the series is back to its original format, starting at the Dursleys. We are quickly reminded that Voldemort’s rebirth only happened a few weeks prior to the current date and we are now seeing the aftermath, or lack thereof in Harry’s perspective. He is totally blocked-off by all useful communications with the Wizarding World and this frustrates him to no end! Sure he gets the Daily Prophet, but barely reads it thinking anything pertaining to Voldemort would be front page worthy. Perhaps the only interesting tidbit is the recurring dream he has of seeing a locked door at the end of a hallway. I remember not thinking much of this when I first read the books, as there were more captivating things to think about, but reading it again, I fully comprehend the magnitude of this dream. It is really foreshadowing at its best, although foreshadowing through dreams is not that original of a technique. As soon as you start reading this book, you get sucked into a whirlwind of events that don’t stop till the very end of the book.