I hated this
book the first time I read it. This is the only volume in the entire series
that I’ve read only once. That makes this my second time reading it and I have
to admit I had a big change of heart. My appreciation for this book was so
radically altered the second time around that it stuck out in the back of my
mind while reading. “Oh, this bit is better than I remembered.” “I don’t even
remember this part. This is really well done.” The differences in my response
to this book from the first and second time reading it will forever colour my
reaction and response to the entire series. My initial response to The Deathly Hallows is partly
responsible for my waning interest in the franchise throughout the last few
years. One thing is for sure, The Deathly
Hallows is a very good book. It might not be surprising to hear this from
fans of the final book in the Harry
Potter series. It’s a new discovery for me and I’m glad I can finally
appreciate what this book has to offer because all of the major elements of the
series get wrapped up and explained at length.
Before starting
the Harry Potter reread I was already
very familiar with books 1 to 5 because I had reread them all so many times
during my teens. I remembered pretty large chunks of the sixth book, some of it
in detail, some of it only vaguely. The final book was more or less completely
unremembered. If you were to ask me what it was about I would have told you the
book is about Harry, Ron, and Hermione bumming around in the forests of Great
Britain doing a shit ton of slacking off and whining about how Dumbledore
failed as the protector of the Wizarding World since he didn’t provide Harry
and the gang with any useful information. Sure, they do bum around in the
middle of the forests and any other secluded area they can find, but the book
is about more than that. The only part of the book I remembered were the parts
I had really disliked. I remembered the bitching and moaning, the terrible
epilogue, and everything else, everything that was and is really good about the
book, has remained forgotten until just a few weeks ago.
The Deathly Hallows has its problems but the strengths of the
story, the culmination of the plot from previous books, and the delightful
character moments sprinkled throughout make it a worthwhile read.
Abandoning
the Formula:
Rowling has been
playing with the formula she established in the first book since The Goblet of Fire. Before then,
previous books were focused primarily on Harry going to Hogwarts, getting
involved with a dangerous mystery, and saving the school with the help of his
friends. As the series progressed, the scope of the Wizarding World expanded well
beyond the school’s grounds. This development was mirrored by the increasingly
detailed world building and addition of characters. Rowling could easily have
continued to tell stories similar to those she had done with the first three
books but that would have been doing a disservice to her fans and to the series.
Instead, she developed the story, the world, and the characters in a way that
they all worked together to make a believable and enchanting saga. It’s not
just set dressing as a lot of these added elements play a significant role in
the continuation of Harry’s story. All of which comes crashing together in the
final book.
The changes to
the formula were one of the reasons I didn’t like The Deathly Hallows the first time I read it. Now I can appreciate
that Rowling needed to break the formula in order to accomplish everything she
needed to do with the final book. During the reread I’ve enjoyed seeing how
Rowling bends and stretches the formula in books four, five, and six. She
played around with it but she always kept the foundational elements in place
(summer at the Dursleys, Hogwarts, return to the Dursleys). Rowling had several
good reasons to head in a different direction. Most of all, there were a lot of
plot elements that needed to be wrapped up and Harry, Ron, and Hermione all had
some serious growing up to do (ok, a less for Hermione).
By abandoning
the formula of the series, Rowling gives the book one of its principal
strengths. By treating Dumbledore’s death as final (something which is often
ignored in fantasy stories) the characters also have to accept it as final and
are forced to make tough decisions. The trio’s decision not to return to
Hogwarts is a primary example. That decision strongly echoes the loss of
Dumbledore. Harry hasn’t just lost his mentor and protector, but he’s also realizes
that he needs to escape from the haven that is Hogwarts. By not going back to
school, the characters and the reader are forced to feel the effects of
Dumbledore’s passing.
Hogwarts has
always acted as an anchor, keeping everything squarely in place, in order. It
also prevented the story from existing beyond its physical location. That’s no
longer true. Outside, wandering throughout the Muggle World and the Wizarding
World, the trio is in more danger than they’ve ever been. Had they remained at
Hogwarts they would also have been in many dangerous situations but as awful as
the conditions are at the school, it’s nothing compared to what Harry, Ron, and
Hermione have to deal with during the seventh book. The students experienced
the kind of cruelty and danger present at the school during the fifth year. The
events happening at Hogwarts during The
Deathly Hallows can be seen as a progression of the mistreatment suffered
by the students at the hands of Umbridge during The Order of the Phoenix. What occurs outside of the school is much
more life-threatening and dangerous than what the students are dealing with.
Students, who I have to point out, are still under the protection of professors
who support Harry and his quests. Their authority is limited but it’s still
there.
Additionally,
it’s important to the point out that the fight against Voldemort could not have
been done from within the walls of Hogwarts. The final battle ultimately takes
places there, but it’s not because Harry intentionally made his final stand at
the school. It’s also not because it’s an important place for Harry in regards
to the battle. Certainly, it was an important place for him during his formative
years as a student. It continues to be an important place for witches and
wizards. The final battle takes place there because the hunt for Horcruxes and
for Hallows let Voldemort and Harry there. Hogwarts is a pivotal location
because, like Harry, it was Voldemort’s home for a very important period of his
life and it affected his development as a wizard and as an adult. His emotional
and magical attachment to the school is what gives Hogwarts a symbolic and
strategic importance.
Leaving Hogwarts
behind and for most of the book must have been a difficult choice for Rowling.
It is, by far, the most iconic location of the entire Wizarding World. When you
think of Harry Potter you immediately
think of Hogwarts and all the wonderful things that have taken place there. Yet
this departure from the formula of the series has been the seventh book
greatest asset and it has allowed it to free itself, narratively speaking. The
result is a series that more closely resembles classic or traditional fantasy
novels. In a previous post I characterized Harry
Potter as wainscot fantasy. It’s not urban fantasy even though the
Wizarding World is hidden in the real world and it’s certainly not your typical
medieval or pseudo-medieval setting. The
Deathly Hallows changes a lot of that by redefining Harry’s story while also
providing a clearer direction in which to steer the series towards the finish
line.
Danish cover of The Deathly Hallows. |
Traditional
fantasy novels often deal with a prophesized saviour of the world and the quest
they must undertake. The Order of the
Phoenix cemented Harry’s status as the chosen one for all the readers who
weren’t yet convinced. It’s only with the end of the sixth book do we get a
glimpse at the totality of Harry’s quest, beyond the obvious need to put an end
to Voldemort. During The Half-Blood Prince Dumbledore explains to
Harry about the Horcruxes. In order to defeat Voldemort you must first ensure
that he cannot return by destroying highly magical and very dangerous objects
known as Horcruxes. Each one of those objects contains a fragment of
Voldemort’s soul. By the beginning of the final book the gang still has five
Horcruxes to find and to destroy. That in itself is a huge undertaking. Once
again Rowling changes up the formula. Most of the books prior to this one
focused on one element in particular whether it’s the Chamber of Secrets or the
Triwizard Tournament. By the middle of the seventh book Rowling introduces a
secondary quest for Harry and his friends.
After their
visit with Xenophilius Lovegood, Harry, Ron, and Hermione, learn about the
Deathly Hallows. Most witches and wizards born of magical parents are already
familiar with the Deathly Hallows having heard of them in one of the many
version of the Tale of the Three Brothers, a fairy tale of sorts. In the story,
three brothers cheat Death after each creating a tool in which to fool him. The
three objects are the Elder Wand, the Resurrection Stone, and the Invisibility
Cloak. The trio is told that a person who can collect all three objects and
uses them successfully will become the Master of Death. After learning of this
they start to understand what Voldemort is up to. Thanks to Harry’s connection
with him they’ve been able to keep a track record of what he’s been doing in
the months since the end of Harry’s sixth year at Hogwarts. They find out he’s
been looking for the Elder Wand. The second quest isn’t just another journey to
collect magical items, though it is that. It’s also a race against Voldemort
with the goal of preventing him from amassing all of the Deathly Hallows but
also to be able to use them against him in order to defeat the Horcruxes and
put an end to his tyranny.
One of the
structural elements of the series that Rowling holds onto is the info dump
chapter at the end of the book. It’s been part of the formula since the very
beginning, since the first book. Because Rowling is a big fan of mysteries she
continues to structure her stories in ways that the characters are almost
always looking for explanations of strange situations. In this book, finding
out the truth about the Deathly Hallows and finding the location of all of the
Horcruxes are the pivotal elements that drive the plot. There are other
interesting mysteries at play but the biggest one is extremely unexpected. The
revelation of the influence that Snape has had on Harry’s life is a spectacular
chapter. It’s shortly followed by another great chapter where Harry meets the
defeated Voldemort in Limbo and has a chat with the still deceased Dumbledore.
These chapters
are essentially exposition and ex post
facto explanations of what truly took place. If nothing else, these chapters show that
Rowling didn’t completely abandon the structure she’s used in the previous
novels. Some elements are still there and are recognizable to those looking for
them. There’s actually more exposition at the end of this book than any other
but Rowling continues to make it thrilling to read so it’s easy to forgive her
indulgence. Besides, I bet those chapters were very difficult to write and
ultimately they did what they were intended to do which was to surprised and
inform the reader. It’s very interesting to see just how closely the narrative
requirements and the novel’s structure support each other, resulting in a very
satisfying read.
Lost in the
Forest – Story Elements that Simply Don’t Work:
There are two
things I particularly dislike about the seventh book and one entire segment
that I think was a missed opportunity. The first thing I’ve mentioned several
times already. The time that Harry, Ron, and Hermione spend in hiding is one of
the worst moments of the entire series. It really brings the quality down for the
whole book.
Their time spent
in the forest was almost unreadable. The whole thing is distinctly uneventful
compared to the rest of the book but also compared to the rest of the series.
The gang has demonstrated time and again that they are proactive, clever, and
resourceful. Bumming around in their tents in the middle of nowhere, all they
do is complain that they have no leads or clues, bitch and moan, and get into
fights with each other resulting in Ron’s departure from the team. They’re far
too passive to be the heroes of the story. You could argue that it’s refreshing
to see them so vulnerable and uncertain, but I think it simply undermines their
characters and their strength as a team. We’ve seen them vulnerable before and
they get plenty of other opportunities in this very book to fail and screw up
before they’re able to succeed in their mission. The whole sequence is
unnecessarily long and drawn out.
Not only is the
group passive but they’re extraordinarily lucky to overhear nearby campers one
faithful night. Their information gathering turned out to be nothing more than
dumb luck. They’re so incredibly reactive that the events of the book make them
look like incompetent buffoons. It’s like their problems with food. They
complain about it and instead of doing something about they simply continue to
starve and grumble. Hey, Harry or Hermione maybe put that polyjuice potion to
good use. Change your appearance and walk in to a Muggle grocery store. Or, go
to a farm and Accio some crops your way. They’re so engrossed in their own
self-pity (“Dumbledore didn’t write me a How To manual on defeating Voldemort,
waaaah”) that they’re not even capable of meeting basic survival needs.
Another example
of their self-pity is there lack of effort in trying to destroy the locket
after they stole it at the Ministry. It makes sense that they don’t know how to
destroy it. It’s powerful magic, after all, but you could try! Instead, they
sit around and mope.
Before the
reread I remembered very little about the final book. To me it seems as though
the entire thing happened in the tent in the forest. I also remember Ron
leaving because he and Harry were being assholes with each other. It's so dumb.
Harry is being an asshole to him even though he knows Ron is being influenced
by the locket. I really don't like that part of the book because it feels like
a cheap way of getting the trio to separate. Rowling is using a magical item
within her fictional universe to create conflict for her characters. It would
have been more interesting for this to happen without magical influence,
especially since the locket builds on the emotions that are already present in
a person. She could have built conflict on that instead of using magic as a
catalyst.
Another misstep
of The Deathly Hallows has to do with
what comes after the battle with Voldemort is won. I’m talking, of course,
about the epilogue. The epilogue is nothing but poor fan service. The whole
thing is ham-fisted and feels forced. I’m pleased to learn that many of our
favourite characters were able to find happiness in their lives after the war
ended. The epilogue should have worked better though. Chronologically it’s set
far enough after the events of the rest of the book for enough time to pass and
heal any wounds of the war. That wasn’t enough though because Rowling seems set
in given us the polar opposite in tone than what she gave us for the last few
books. Everything in the epilogue is sickly sweet. Everyone is too similar to
how we know them twelve odd years earlier. It’s as if the characters grew in
age, advanced forward in time, but have completely stopped developing as unique
individuals. Adult Harry is the same as teenaged Harry. It doesn’t feel right. It's
almost as if the characters are unable to develop without the threat of a cataclysmic
conflict.
Speaking of
cataclysmic conflicts, the Battle of Hogwarts feels like a missed opportunity
for me. It should have been large, filled with more characters and more
viewpoints. There are so many excellent secondary characters and Rowling puts
them all on the sidelines and opts instead to focus on Harry. I get it, Harry’s
the hero, but we’ve also spent far too much time with him being depressed and
in hiding. We want some action and he’s got way too much on his mind to provide
us with the insight into the battle readers (myself included) have been
expecting for years. This is the final showdown and it pales in comparison to
previous big climactic scenes in other books.
The Order of the Phoenix is a difficult book to read because of
Harry’s teenaged crisis, but the invasion of the Ministry by Dumbledore’s Army
is a clear highpoint for the entire series. Even the final stage of the
Triwizard Tournament and Voldemort’s resurrection are far more interesting than
what we get with the Battle of Hogwarts. Don’t get me wrong, I enjoyed it, but
the action was far too focused on Harry to provide me with the adequate
grandiosity the battle deserved. I can only surmise that Rowling doesn’t excel
at this sort of thing. Her strengths are clearly pacing, plotting, and
characterization. She’s not bad at action, but she’s not really good at large
battles either. As a fantasy fan I’ve read my share of these sorts of chapters
and Rowling skills in this area simply don’t compare with what other authors
can do. The Battle of Hogwarts was far from being a bad part of the book. It’s
just a little disappointing because it had so much potential.
Writing a
Memorable Finale – The Good Stuff:
While I have
quite few reservations for some parts of the final book, I happen to really
like the rest of it. It’s impressive just how much quality storytelling Rowling
manages to fit within its pages. While I love to complain about Harry, Ron, and
Hermione’s self-pitying and in-fighting during their time in hiding, once they
get it into their heads that they’re taking action, the book simply doesn’t
stop. It quickly builds momentum and sustains it until the last page of the
book. The book’s momentum is my explanation as to why so many people actually make
it to the end of the prologue instead of abandoning after the first page. In my
opinion, the best thing about The Deathly
Hallows is Rowling’s devotion to her characters, regardless of their
overall importance to the series. Being a series of fantasy novels targeted at
young adult readers, it was pretty safe to think that the forces of good would
defeat the forces of evil by the end of the book. Sure, any protection Harry
used to have no longer applied (his mother’s protection wore off after he left
the Dursleys’ home and turned seventeen and Dumbledore’s passing naturally put
an end to any direct assistance Dumbledore could provide). By maintaining the
reader’s interest in secondary and tertiary characters, readers are more
emotionally invested in the outcome of the story beyond the expected triumph
over Voldemort.
Rowling starts wrapping up loose character threads early
on in the book, beginning with the Dursleys. The goodbye with the Dursleys was well written. Dudley’s last words with
Harry were particularly enjoyable to read. It felt earnest but still very
awkward as befits their relationship throughout the years. He's grown up and
matured and he's found a reason to respect Harry. You don't get the sense that
he’s come to like Harry, at least not much, but he certainly respects him. I
think Dudley may also have come to realize just how poorly his cousin has been
mistreated by his parents for his entire life. He might be feeling apologetic
for that. It might be a combination of those things in addition to his
brainwashed dislike and suspicion of the Wizarding World. He shows potential
for further maturity and I can almost make out a future for him where he
marries a witch to the surprise and disappointment of his parents. At the very
least, he realizes that Muggles aren't alone in the world and they share their
existence on the planet with witches and wizards. You might as well get used to
the idea and that both communities influence the goings-on of the other group.
I also like how
quickly Harry embraces this growth of character. You could easily forgive him
if he had reacted more negatively to Dudley's statement. It's an indication of
Harry's character, something he's always had in him but perhaps has further
developed under the influence and guidance of Dumbledore, that he so easily
embraces the good in people; even in people who show their negative qualities
more often than their positive ones. There is good in everyone and though it took
time for it to surface, Dudley is showing that spark for good, at last. I could
hardly think of a better way to present Harry's departure from the Dursleys’
life.
One of the strengths of long series is that writers who
know how to tell a good story will have their characters change and grow over
the course of time. Harry Potter
follows a format where one school year is covered in each book. This allows for
plenty of character growth opportunities since the time that passes from the
beginning of the series to its end can be traced in years. This had led to a
few really great character moments in The
Deathly Hallows. One of my favourites is Remus Lupin’s transformation (no,
not into a werewolf). After learning that his wife, Tonks, is pregnant, Lupin
experiences an emotional breakdown. The Second Wizarding War has taken its toll
on him and his has doubts about his marriage and relationship with Tonks. It’s
not that he doesn’t love her anymore, much to the contrary. He’s simply fearful
about how his lycanthropy will get in the way and prevent them from leading a
normal family life. He’s also very concerned that he may have passed on his
condition to his as-of-yet unborn child. Seeing such a strong character reduced
to an unstable person is shocking to readers. It’s also an effective way to
demonstrate how the changes in the world are affecting people. Rowling does a
fabulous job showing us a consequence of war that isn’t a character dying.
Another character who can’t seem to deal with the Second Wizarding
War is Xenophilius Lovegood. Since Voldemort made his return public, Lovegood
has chosen to support Harry with The Quibbler but he decides to write defamatory
articles about Harry after the Voldemort’s forces have kidnapped Luna, his
daughter. Still, Lovegood is not a bad person but his change in behaviour
reflects the personal consequences of the Second Wizarding War. He wants to
protect his daughter and in order to do this he accepts that he has to betray
the Wizarding community and its potential saviour. Yet he mostly does this
publicly. He still helps the trio when he informs them of the Deathly Hallows
even though his intentions weren’t really to help them. After all, he could
very well be telling them information he believes to be unimportant (it’s often
regarded as just another bedtime story) in order to keep them in his house
while waiting for Death Eaters to arrive. He’s initially brisk and distant when
answering the door and it quickly changes to an invitation for tea (gurdyroot,
actually) and supper when he understands that he has an opportunity to help his
daughter. He doesn't do this for the greater good. He does it for himself and
for his daughter. Lovegood's wife died several years ago and Luna is all he has
left. He's in a situation where he doesn't believe he can help both the trio
and Luna. He’s forced to make a difficult decision and he chooses to protect
his daughter. Deep down he must know that he'll be betrayed by Voldemort and
the Death Eaters but I don't think he cares at that point. He's willing to try
anything he can for Luna’s sake.
How could I forget about Dobby? I didn't even mention him! I'll miss him so much. |
There are plenty of other characters who have their
moment to shine. Kreacher’s change of heart is impressive and unexpected. He’s
been nothing but a miserable shit in the previous books but he turns over a new
leaf in The Deathly Hallows and now
he’s willing to help Harry when he’s asked to do so. Plenty of other characters
have changed because of the war and Rowling provides us with many examples of
this throughout the book. Bill and
Fleur’s decision to get married speaks volumes about the reassurance love can
bring even in the darkest of days. Fred and George Weasley’s shop in Diagon
Alley being one of the few places that hasn’t been abandoned or boarded up
shows us that laughter is always welcome, even in dire times. Neville and
Ginny’s leadership of what’s left of Dumbledore’s Army at Hogwarts is also
great character work by Rowling. Harry is the hero of the entire series but
there are plenty of heroics going on aside from what he, Ron, and Hermione are
doing. The younger generation of witches and wizards have, in part, inherited a
war from their parents. Neville and many other teens have witnesses the
negative effects of the First Wizarding War and even though they’re scarred and
regularly find themselves in dangerous situations, they’re not going to roll
over. They’re making a stand wherever they can and they’re fighting for what
they believe is right. It’s unimportant whether they’re doing it out of
self-preservation, out of self-sacrifice, in the hopes of righting past wrongs,
or to protect others unable to protect themselves. What’s important is that
they’re taking charge and fighting for their beliefs and for a peaceful way of
life.
We also get a lot of development of existing characters who have been important to the series since the first book. Some of my favourites include further development of Harry, Dumbledore, Voldemort, and Snape.
We also get a lot of development of existing characters who have been important to the series since the first book. Some of my favourites include further development of Harry, Dumbledore, Voldemort, and Snape.
As much as I
dislike bitchy teenaged Harry, this book helped me sympathize with him more
than the overly emotional all-caps Harry from The Order of the Phoenix. At one point in the series, between the
fourth and fifth books, my sympathy for Harry transformed into annoyance. This
book has a pretty equal serving of both but that balance was refreshing.
Mostly, I agree with a lot of what Harry had to say about Dumbledore. Why was he
so mysterious in all the years that Harry had known him? Why didn’t he openly
tell Harry what his plans were? This is especially confounding after the
emotional breakdown he had with Harry at the end of the fifth book. Sure,
readers can try and offer explanations such as “Dumbledore didn’t know he was
going to die!” or other. You have to remember, he was hunting Horcruxes and he
even took the time to make Harry agree to do whatever he was going to ask of
him. He knew he was walking into a potentially fatal situation. He knew ever since
he found the ring of Salazar Slytherin. I love Dumbledore but his behaviour has
been questionable on more than one occasion and it’s easy to be frustrated with
that when the fate of the world literally rests on your shoulders, as it’s the
case for Harry.
Though it’s not
entirely surprising, Rowling develops Dumbledore’s character significantly in
this volume. I say it’s not surprising because even after his death in the
previous book, Rowling had to find a way of keeping his presence felt in the final
volume. Lucky for us, she basically does for Dumbledore what she did for
Voldemort in The Half-Blood Prince.
Essentially, she delves into his past and fleshes him out. Learning about a
youthful Dumbledore we’re forced to consider him under a different light than
we did previously. I like that Rowling shows us Dumbledore’s past without
reverting to the pensieve because it’s something that’s already been used
enough in the series and it will be used later on for delving into Snape’s
memories. Instead, she uses newspaper articles, excerpts from Rita Skeeter’s
biography of Dumbledore, and stories told to Harry by friends of Dumbledore.
This intentionally creates a more ambiguous history of the former Hogwarts
headmaster and it’s fitting. After all, he’s always been a very mysterious and
nuanced character. We learn a lot more about Dumbledore but there are still
quite a few secrets hidden away.
It would have
been a shame not to provide us with more Voldemort in the final book considering
he’s the main antagonist and Rowling doesn’t disappoint. After the fantastic
development of Voldemort in The
Half-Blood Prince, Rowling continues to expand on the previous books. What
I really like is the idea that Voldemort has been unaware of the Deathly
Hallows for most of his life. He’s always had an interest in dark magic but not
in legends that are derivative of bedtime stories. He likely did a ton of
research in various dark magic subjects during his life but the Tale of the
Three Brothers wasn’t worthy of his attention being nothing but a story for
children. Or so he thought.
Consider the
people who believe in the Hallows. It's never been mentioned as something
serious by characters other than the trio and Lovegood, at least not until near
the end of the book where the truth becomes too obvious to ignore. Characters
like Ron who grew up in a wizard household dismisses the story of the Hallows
as a fairy tale for teaching children lessons. He, and likely many other
witches and wizards, doesn't take the story seriously. He never thought of it
as a something that could be real. If it wasn't for Harry's invisibility cloak
it's quite likely that Lovegood would not have convinced them that the Hallows
really existed. Even then Harry had to consider and puzzle together some of the
knowledge Dumbledore gave him before acknowledging the existence of the Hallows.
What make all of this interesting in regards to Voldemort is that he’s tried
everything he could try short of investigating legends and fairy tales. He’s
desperate. He knows his Horcruxes are being hunted and destroyed. He’s willing
to try anything else to help him grow in power and extend his dominance over
others, including a search for potentially non-existent items such as the
Hallows. If he can’t cheat death with the Horcruxes he’s going to try and master
it with the Hallows.
The final
character whose complexity jumped in leaps and bound with the final book is
Snape. You could argue he’s as mysterious as Dumbledore. Either that or he’s
incredibly misleading. It’s always difficult to trust a double-agent and Snape
is no exception. Most of his development is done in a single chapter, though his
action in the final book and the explanation of his actions in the rest of the series
are so revealing that it left me reeling. It’s such a well-crafted chapter in
how it builds one revelation on the next one that I find it difficult to
describe without simply summarizing it. If it wasn’t clear before, this chapter
announces to the world that Snape is one of the most complex characters in the
entire series, probably more so than Voldemort, Dumbledore, or Harry. He’s also
one of the most sympathetic once you get to know his side of the story. As
Dumbledore once said to Snape, “You are braver man by far than Igor Karkaroff.
You know, I sometime think we Sort too soon…”. Snape was never hungry for power
like many of his Slytherin brothers and sisters. In truth, he’s been bravely fighting
for what he believes in longer than most and with his final years as one of
Harry’s protectors, he played an immense role in Harry’s education and in dethroning
Voldemort.
Final
Thoughts on The Deathly Hallows:
With the seventh
book, Rowling skilfully changes the narrative of the Harry Potter series while also respecting the previous books’
continuity. She takes the story and presents a progression that feels both
natural and one that is also full of surprises. The Deathly Hallows resembles a traditional fantasy novel more than
any other before it but everything maintains the style and tone of Harry Potter. The final book in the saga
is a double quest narrative combined with the overarching story of the chosen
one, or in this case, the Boy Who Lived.
Rowling really
knows how to tie up a series. She provides readers with plenty of strong
character moments with some of our favourite residents of the Wizarding World
while also managing to keep the focus of the story on the main characters. Somehow,
almost every character that played an important role in any of the previous books
either gets a great send-off or their moment to shine and remind us while we
love them so much. Even more surprisingly, Rowling manages to do this while
presenting us with the realistic consequences of the Second Wizarding War and
continuing to develop characters that aren’t part of the main trio.
It’s wonderful
to consider just how tightly plotted this book is. Rowling must have had a hell
of a time keeping track of which character knew what about Harry’s quests, the
Horcruxes, and the Deathly Hallows. I’m shocked to discover that I so quickly
dismissed this book for being slow and boring when I first read it. Certainly,
the gang’s time in the forest is still boring as hell but there are plenty of
well written and very tense moments throughout the book to keep me entertained.
From the moment Harry, Ron, and Hermione decide to break into Gringotts all the
way to the last page The Deathly Hallows
is a thrilling page-turner of a novel.
Random Thoughts:
As always, let’s
end with some random thoughts. There are few compared to previous posts and I’m
a little bit sorry for that but I had such a good time reading the seventh book
that I barely took the time to write down any notes and thoughts while reading.
The short random thoughts section is also a blessing in disguise. Consider it
an invitation to sound off with your own random thoughts about the entire
series in the comments section. Go!
RT: The Battle of the Seven Harrys is tense, exciting, and emotionally devastating. It's live or die in the Wizarding World.
RT: Noberta, the
Norwegian Ridgeback from the first book. That’s a hilarious call back to a
previous event.
RT: Hermione's exclamation of "Merlin's pants!" is my favourite expletive in the whole series. Merlin's beard is alright but it feels a little on the nose while the use of pants is just odd enough to make it work. Don't all wizards in the novels wear robes? Why did Merlin wear pants? I love it.
RT: Voldemort's name is Taboo. By making his name Taboo he’s able to send Death Eaters to the exact location of whoever used his name. Now you really know why people were so afraid to speak his name in the earlier books.
RT: Hermione's exclamation of "Merlin's pants!" is my favourite expletive in the whole series. Merlin's beard is alright but it feels a little on the nose while the use of pants is just odd enough to make it work. Don't all wizards in the novels wear robes? Why did Merlin wear pants? I love it.
RT: Voldemort's name is Taboo. By making his name Taboo he’s able to send Death Eaters to the exact location of whoever used his name. Now you really know why people were so afraid to speak his name in the earlier books.
RT: The series
needs more Aberforth Dumbledore. I love him. Can we get a spin-off series,
please?
No comments:
Post a Comment