Showing posts with label Peter David. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Peter David. Show all posts

Wednesday, 26 November 2014

Star Trek: The Next Generation: Imzadi review


One of the greatest disappointments of The Next Generation is that poor use of Troi and Riker’s romantic past. It was made quite clear in the very first episode that they had a romantic relationship in the past and while that wasn’t something that needed to be immediately defined in the show, it could have led to some very interesting stories. Instead, it’s mostly ignored for the duration of the series only to be picked up again in the movies and neatly wrapped up, without really developing the characters or their relationship. I was pleased to discover that there exists a novel that expands on this relationship, mostly but focusing on Riker and Troi’s past. I was doubly pleased that it’s written by Peter David, one of my favourite Star Trek writers.

The great thing about Star Trek and many other heavily detailed and expansive fictional universes or settings is that overtime the fictional world develops to such a degree that it can then be used to tell any kind of story at all. Similarly to how literary fiction has dabbled in other genres to tell specific stories, franchises have and continue to do the same. Two Star Wars books come to mind as good examples of what I’m trying to say: Death Troopers (horror), Kenobi (western). For most of Star Trek’s best episodes and stories (films, books, comics) the main idea is one about travel into the unknown and discovery of unusual cultures and the adventures that the characters have had are used in a way to shed light on our own behaviour. As such, Star Trek can and has been used effectively as a way to hold up a mirror on contemporary matters and provide a catalyst for reflection and thought on complicated issues. It’s often done in combination with action and adventure stories.

While the TV series have focused a lot of adventure the media tie-in novels have spends a great deal of time following up on Starfleet’s initial encounters with civilization or strange inhabitants of the universe. The novels are also particularly interesting for providing us with additional information on people and events taking place before and after a particular series or movie.

Which bring us to Imzadi. As I’ve come to expect from David, his novels effortlessly balance big ideas, strong characterization and humour. The results have always been good (at least on the novels he’s written solo). In that respect Imzadi is par for the course but it does have more problems with it than I initially expected. My expectations are the result of the commentary I’ve read online, claiming Imzadi as David’s best TNG novel. The rest of it was made up by my personal thoughts on the relationship between Riker and Troi. I simply expected something a little bit longer and more involved than what David writes.  

Imzadi begins with a rather dark introduction set in the future, about 40 years after the end of TNG. The sense of adventure and hopeful energy that is characteristic of many television episodes is gone. When Commodore Data spends as much time thinking about the past than he does thinking about the present and the future, it’s telling. He’s been characterized as incredibly curious and while he still shows some of that curiosity in the book’s first chapter, he’s also preoccupied with the past. You get to see his future self contrasting with his TNG-era self later in the novel when two time periods collide. It could be that his curiosity has shifted towards deeper understanding of existing knowledge as opposed to discovery but I think it suggests the overall feeling of the United Earth’s Federation at the time the story of Imzadi begins.

The first few chapters also introduce us to an older William Riker, now an Admiral. He no longer cares about his duty to Starfleet or his career. He feels as though he’s peaked (and he has) and as the commander of Starbase 86 he’s coasting until the end of his days. It takes an element of the past to rouse him into action and even that isn’t much of a rousing, initially. David introduces another character from TNG who eventually starts a fire in Riker who then takes it upon himself to bring his eternal love back to life by using the Guardian of Forever and changing the past.

David uses the novel to bring the reader to the very beginning of Riker and Troi’s relationship. He spends about half the novel developing their romance which has only been hinted at in the show. This is where David fails, in my opinion. There are several things about Riker and Troi’s relationship that I don’t like. For starters, they both seem to be competing with each other. I don’t get the sense that Troi likes Riker for who he is. Instead, she immediately tries to change him. As for Riker, he tries to pretend he doesn’t have the personality that Troi says he has (even though her analysis of him is spot on). They eventually come to love each other but only after Riker rescues Troi from and intergalactic art thieves who kidnapped her. The most frustrating part isn’t that Troi is the damsel in distress; it’s that everything feels forced. David’s humour also gets in the way of their romance and it doesn’t work nearly as well as I would have hoped. I can’t help feeling that Troi only likes Riker because she believes they’re imzadi which is a Betazed version of soulmates. She feels connected to Riker and he to her but because it happened during sex, it comes off as them simply having incredible sex in the middle of the jungle. It’s a type of romance, sure, but not what I was expecting.

Despite all of these problems, David continues to prove that he has a knack for writing the characters of TNG. He understands them and their mannerisms shine through on the page. Data (present and future versions), Picard, Riker (past, present and future versions) and Troi (past, present and future versions) are all spot on. I might not have liked the romance chapters but all the characters from the TV series stay true to how they’re portrayed on television. It’s likely because of his firm grasp of these characters that he created such believable versions of their younger and future selves. That leads right into the highlight of this book which is the excellent time travel adventure. David sets it up beautifully and it pays of expertly in the final few chapters.

I also really like how his use of the Guardian of Forever and the TOS episode “The City on the Edge of Forever”. I really like it when Star Trek novels elaborate on the implication of discoveries the Enterprise and her crew made in an episode. David does that here with the Guardian where we learn that a there is a crew living on the planet who job it is to observe and record the Guardian. They study it, record what it says and try to live with the negative psychological influence it has on them. While it might be fun and exciting (as well as dangerous, let’s admit) to make all these discoveries it can be significantly less exciting and equally dangerous to have to deal with those discoveries. Studying the Guardian is described as a thankless task. It’s difficult and there is seemingly little pay off. This somewhat bleak look at Starfleet is important and while not all the novels share this view of Star Trek I’m glad that there are some as it shows an important facet of the franchise and it serves to add quite a bit of depth to the series as there were a lot of TV episodes that lived in a vacuum. This sense of continuity, not in the sense of minute details studied by Trekkie trivia buffs, but in the sense that stories depicted in past episodes are either remembered or continue to progress one the Enterprise and its crew have flown away, is a highlight of the Star Trek novels.
  
I’d like to talk about more details but I fear that doing so would ruin the novel. I had a great time reading about the different time periods and following the narrative while it weaved between past, present and future. It’s an impressive feat that David combined so many elements that make Star Trek good, considering those elements rarely work so well together. As I said above, the weakest part of this book was the chapters focusing on Riker and Troi’s first few weeks together and it does affect the rest of the narrative. If you can’t believe in their love you can’t believe in Riker’s actions and the important of Troi to his life and (though it’s never shown from her point of view) Riker’s importance to Troi. Imzadi isn’t David’s best Star Trek novel but it is very enjoyable. The breadth and scope of the story is impressive even though he doesn’t quite pull it off as expertly as I would have hoped. There are still numerous reasons to read this book. If you’ve a fan of David’s writing, curious about Riker and Troi’s relationship, enjoy a time travel story, would like to see a TNG version (though reverse version) of “The City on the Edge of Forever”, you owe it to yourself to pick up this book. As long as you don’t expect too much from the book’s romance chapters you’re guaranteed to have a good time.


Saturday, 5 July 2014

X-Factor: The Complete Collection volume 1 review


X-Factor collects Madrox, a five issue mini-series and the first 12 issues of the third X-Factor series written by Peter David. I previously reviewed David’s run on the first X-Factor series during the early nineties and while there were some good ideas in that series, the highlight was really the character development. It’s unfortunate that there wasn’t a lot of it and the series was plagued by a lack of focus (crossovers with other titles including one major crossover between all the existing X-tittles at the time) and inconsistent art. It made for a run that had quite a bit of potential but ultimately it fell short on providing a good story or even serving as quality entertainment.

Lucky for us all, David got another shot at these characters. Though I’ve only read about two years’ worth of issues, I think it’s pretty safe to say that X-Factor is one of the best X-men comics to come out in the last ten years. The reason is pretty simple; the series doesn’t focus on telling Good versus Evil stories by way of superhero fights. Instead, David focuses on the day to day operations of Madrox Investigations in a post-House of M Marvel universe and how this affects the characters and their relationship to one another.


Madrox #1-5:
It’s my first time reading Madrox and while I wouldn’t say it’s essentially to read in order to understand and enjoy X-Factor, it provides plenty of additional information regarding the setup of the ongoing series and some of the characters that would round out the regular cast. The idea of Madrox is a simple one: what if a Madrox decided to open a private detective office for mutants? Heavily influenced by noir films, David creates a new chapter in Jamie Madrox’s life. Also known as the Multiple Man, Madrox was part of the government sanctioned X-Factor team of the 90s. That incarnation of X-Factor started under David’s guidance and continued after his departure from the title. After leaving the team, Madrox worked for one of Professor Xavier’s X-Corporation offices which was located in Paris. After acquiring a million dollars cheating on a televised game show and uses the money to open up XXX Investigations in the heart of Mutant Town in New York.

Madrox obviously focuses on the character of Madrox and while it also serves to introduce the concept of XXX Investigations, that’s mostly part of the setting and serves as a B-plot to occupy Guide “Strong Guy” Carosella and Rahne “Wolfsbane” Sinclair. David takes a rather bland X-men character and turns him into one of the most interesting characters in the franchise’s history in a mere five issues. He does so by exploring the possibilities of Madrox’s powers and how that changes Madrox and the world around him. For those who might not know it, Madrox has the power to create dupes (short for duplicates) of himself. A concussive force will create a dupe and they have their own personality and autonomy, apart from Madrox prime. Only Madrox prime can reabsorb the dupes and only this ability and the knowledge that he is Madrox prime and the dupes’ self-awareness of being dupes, keeps Madrox as the dominant version of himself. It’s a little complicated, I know, but David complicates things further and it actually improves the character.

Part of his plan to open up a private detective agency was to send out dozens and dozens of dupes around the world to learn various skills, from sports to achieving doctorate levels in various fields of study to becoming a monk. He does this because when he absorbs a dupe, he also absorbs all of the knowledge they acquired when roaming free. While there are obvious perks to sending out dupes and acquiring vast amounts of knowledge and new skills, there are also negative consequences. Madrox prime is starting to feel drawn out. He’s feeling confused and his “internal” dupes (for a lack of a better description) are starting to associate themselves with specific portions of his psyche and they become fully consumed by the part of his psyche that they represent.  In short, his brilliant plan is starting to back fire on him and there is no real way to recall his long range dupes because they’ve attained full autonomy. There’s also no telling when one of those dupes will show up again. It’s a great way to establish the random arrival of a dupe which David uses as a way to introduce new plot elements or to jump start character development. Because this comic is written by David, dupes are also used as way to inject humour in the comic.

The B-plot involving Guido, Rahne and one of the dupes is interesting in itself and it helps to round out the miniseries. It deals with one of the office’s first investigations. One of them is investigating the apparent murder of one of the dupes and Madrox takes care of that one on his own. The other involves mutant marital troubles. A woman asks them to confirm whether or not her husband is having an affair. It’s important to mention that her husband is paralyzed and she thinks he’s cheating with the aid of his astral projection. Weird, mutant related private detective comic? I’m sold.


X-Factor #1-12:
The first issue of X-Factor doesn’t rehash everything that happened during the miniseries but it does present a considerable amount of information regarding Madrox’s powers. David also writes a flashback detailing how Madrox won the money to buy the small apartment building in Mutant Town which now serves as the business location and living quarters for X-Factor Investigations. It’s a a very solid first issue because it simultaneously recaps the Madrox-centric elements from the miniseries, presents the current status of X-Factor Investigations and adds a characters and story elements that the story will focus on. Some of those elements include the problems Madrox is having with his powers, specifically in controlling his dupes, the team’s investigation of what caused M-Day, the arrival of Layla Miller (from the House of M miniseries) a girl who “know stuff”. Another element that becomes important to the series is the budding rivalry with Singularity Investigations, a large PI corporation.

I’m very impressed with just how much David juggles with this series. There is so much going on and most of it is related to characters, what they do, how events in the larger Marvel Universe are affecting them, and how they interact with each other. Perhaps unsurprisingly, because it’s written by Peter David, the series really focuses on characters and everything else stems from that. Aside from Madrox, which is just fascinating to read about, I’m also intrigued by the storytelling potential of Rictor. He lost his powers on M-Day and he’s struggling with that lost. Some days are better than others but his development is engaging. It doesn’t take much time for him to start being useful to the team but I have a feeling that’s because X-Factor Investigations is really dysfunctional at this this point in time and it doesn’t take much for Rictor to provide assistance to the team. There is so much going on that it’s easy to help out. Still, being surrounded by mutants that still have their powers will take its toll on him, even if he’s worked with all of them before.

The other character that really stands out is Layla Miller. She was essentially a plot devise in House of M which was written by Brian Michael Bendis. In David’s capable hands she’s growing into a great character. Like Madrox, her powers are problematic. She “knows things”, things from the past, the present and the future. She also knows about the M-Day incident and she’s actively trying to prevent X-Factor from learning the truth. David could make everything easy for Layla but he powers aren’t infallible. She can’t read Guido too well and when she tries to read Quicksilver she’s often wrong (probably due to his blood relation with the Scarlet Witch and it affects Layla’s ability to read him). She also lies and keeps secrets about the stuff she knows. She doesn’t just know about the future but also which future should happen. When she learns that a member of X-Factor will be severely beaten, beaten close to death, she doesn’t try and stop it because it’s part of the future that should happen. David’s not cryptic about it though, he brings it back a few issues later and explains Layla’s action in a way that feels satisfying, despite the fact that someone was severely beaten. I also like Layla because she and Guido bring a lot of humour to the series.

While Madrox (series) didn't have too much tha set it in a specific time period of Marvel continuity, X-Factor is very much a story that takes place in post-House of M. One of its main characters, Layla, is from the series and the setting, shortly after M-Day, is relevant to the story being told. Still, those elements do not make X-Factor feel dated but they do place the series, a least the beginning of the series, within a specific context of the Marvel shared universe. It’s s little crazy to contemplate that period in Marvel history. Everything was constantly in flux. From Avengers Disassembled, to Hostory and plot of use of M, followed by Decimation and everything leading up to Civil War. It was pretty exciting reading Marvel comics then but sometimes, issues felt gratuitous because their sole reason for existing was to add additional information to these larger event stories. David expertly avoids this with X-Factor. The focus is never on the specifics of the events comics. Instead, it focuses on the effects of those stories on the cast of X-Factor. They’re having their own stories and adventures but everything is informed by the goings-on of the larger Marvel Universe.

It's pretty annoying that a collection like this the credit information is incorrect. It's not all wrong of course, but there are enough mistakes to make it rather embarrassing for the collection editors. Errors include indication the Madrox mini-series is six issues long when it's only five issues long in at least two different places, indicating that the cover art for issues 4 and 5 are by Gabriele Dell'otto and coloured by Jose Villarrubia when you can clearly see Ryan Sook's signature right above Villarrubia's on the cover of issue #5. It makes the whole production look amateurish. I'm almost surprised the issues are all in the correct order of publication. That doesn’t affect the quality of the stories within, because it’s really good stuff. It’s a stellar example of how to write an X-men comic that isn’t focused on a superhero team taking care of battling supervillains or preventing a large scale crisis every other week. I like these fat paperbacks. It’s one of the best ways to enjoy reading an ongoing series and it helps when the issues are as good as these ones. 

Saturday, 26 April 2014

X-Factor Visionaries vol. 4 review

Peter David’s tenure as the writer of X-Factor was, in my opinion, the biggest waste of talent on an X-title during the nineties. David is a good writer and his strength are in good characterizations but he never really got a chance to tell his stories without interruptions. None of the three X-Factor Visionaries volumes have been great. David is having a difficult time finding his footing and hitting his stride on the title. This volume is essentially more of the same but some of the stories within are much worse and some are actually a bit better but volume 4 is the last one of this particular run and it’s probably for the best.

There was an X-Men crossover in the early nineties called X-cutioner’s Song. The event happened in the pages of four different X-Men comics during four months for a total of 12 issues. Three of those issues are collected in this volume. I’ve never read the whole event but if the X-Factor issues are any indication, X-cutioner’s Song is fucking crap. The volume begins with X-Factor’s event issues written by David with art by Jae Lee. I’m a fan of Lee’s artwork. He’s more stylized and formal than many other artists working in comics but based on his work here he’s had very similar beginnings as many other artists who worked nearly twenty years ago. It’s completely different than the kind of thing he would produce now or even ten years ago. It’s sad to say but it’s pretty typical of the kind of stuff you would find in Marvel comics from the early nineties. The characters have grotesquely exaggerated anatomy and their bodies have unnatural sharp corners. The crosshatchings and heavy inking makes for art that is pretty unpalatable. The garish colouring doesn’t help, either. To top it all off, David’s scripting is sub-par compared to the rest of the X-Factor issues. His heart is obviously not in it. For three months during the X-cutioner’s Song event, David was writing this comic because it was a job and not because he enjoyed writing them. It’s just awful stuff. I don’t even know why I’m still talking about it.

After the crossover issues, we finally get some really good X-Factor stories. My favourite is the psychiatrist issue. Val Cooper, government liaison for the team, has decided that all of the members of the team need to a have session with a psychiatrist after particularly difficult missions. In this case, Cooper considers the events of X-cutioner’s Song to qualify as a trying mission for the team. I like that David could take something so bad and make something good out of it. It’s also great to see just how quickly and accurately he explains the character and identifies their individual faults in the psychiatrist sessions. The only ones that don’t really work for me is Polaris and Rahne. Maybe it’s because I’m not very familiar with them as characters but something just doesn’t quite click. Guido’s session was awesome. I really enjoyed his origin story and I appreciated the explanation for his physical deformity. Quicksilver’s was another exemplary bit of storytelling and character development. That story will forever affect how I look at him.

The art also improved with the post-crossover stories. Joe Quesada takes care of the art and though it’s not my favourite kind of style nor is Quesada a favourite artist, it’s a definitive improvement following’s the Lee issues (truly, that’s a sentence I never thought I’d write). It’s with that particular issue that David hits his stride but it’s a short lived celebration since his run ended soon after. The characters and stories are mixing together nicely at this point

Peter David had an interesting run on X-Factor but there were too many inconsistencies in the stories being told, some artist fluctuations, and a terrible X-men crossover all contributed to destroy any momentum David and his collaborators were able to build on the title. Still, for those who can tolerate 90s X-Men comics, there are some good stories to be found in these collections but you’ll also have to deal with some of David’s worst comics (as far as I’ve read anyway). For those of you who want to avoid the drudgery, do yourself a favour and go diving in the long boxes for X-Factor #87. “X-Aminations” is really an excellent done-in-one story, worthy to be compared with some of the best that X-Men comics have to offer. It’s sad that this run never attained full steam but David got to write many of these characters when he helmed the relaunched X-Factor series back in 2005. It’s actually one of the best X-Men series since the early 2000s . . . but that’s another post. 

Wednesday, 2 April 2014

Star Trek: The Next Generation: Vendetta: The Giant Novel review


First off, let's talk about the ridiculousness of the title. Nearly half the cover is made up of words and the rest is made up of what you will typically find on the cover of a Star Trek novel of the 90s: busts of characters from the show and a spaceship in the background. Don’t believe me? Look it up online, you’ll quickly see the pattern, too. Some elements of this cover work though. Keith Birdsong regularly captures the likeness of the actors he’s illustrating and despite giving Picard a thinner face, he nails it. I particularly like the creepy expression of the Borg’s face. The art is standard but very well executed. What’s truly ridiculous on the cover though is the title of the book: Star Trek: The Next Generation: Vendetta: The Giant Novel. Are you serious? Apparently yes because that’s a picture of the final product, right there --->

But what exactly constitutes a “giant novel” by Star Trek standards? It’s clear to anybody who’s look at the details of the book or has seen the physical thing that Vendetta isn’t really giant by anyone’s standards other than those of Pocket Books. Vendetta is exactly 400 pages in length. That’s not much longer than the average Star Trek book published at the time of its release. Let’s consider previous books by Peter David. Strike Zone is 275 pages long, A Rock and a Hard Place is 244 pages and Q-in-Law is 252. So Vendetta has 125 to 150 additional pages. My god, this book is huge! Giant barely does it justice. In truth, I really don’t think this or any of the other giant Star Trek novels are labelled as such specifically because of their length. Having only read one, I think it’s pretty safe to say that they’re considered giant in the sense that they deal with a much larger story and it’s simply consequential that the page count is more than the average Star Trek book.

Vendetta delivers on the big story. Its story is essentially a sequel to “The Best of Both Worlds” from TNG and “The Doomsday Machine” from TOS. Peter combines the planet-killer with multiples Borg cubes to create one big explosion filled novel and, for the most part, it’s quite good. David puts a lot of effort into making this particular story feel big and important which I appreciate because his previous books have felt like additional episodes that were never filled but very well could have and it was nice to get a story so big that one and maybe two episodes wouldn’t have quite been enough to contain the whole novel from start to finish as it’s written here.

The book begins with a flashback during Captain Picard’s day at the Academy where we’re presented the story of his first encounter with the spectre of a woman. This is relevant to the story being told later I the novel but it’s inclusion in the beginning is meant to give the reader a sense of just how big (or giant) this story is supposed to be. I have to say that it feels pretty hollow and it does little to increase the importance of who the woman turns out to be. This chapter is also notable for introducing Morgan Korsmo, a classmate of Picard’s who will also captain a ship in the future. There are some nice moments with Korsmo later on even so; the first chapter seems like and unnecessary. Well, that might not be entirely true. It does sum up “The Doomsday Machine” but if you’re actually reading Vendetta you’re probably already familiar with that episode.

Kirk's Enterprise and their encounter with the first planet-killer.

The story continues with the destruction of the planet Penzatti by the Borg. The Enterprise travels to the planet to aid them and to find out what the Borg are up to. There they encounter a second version of the planet-killer from which is piloted by Guinan’s bond-sister who is consumed by her desire to destroy the Borg for all the suffering they’ve caused her. It might sound like an impossible task but with the planet-killer at her disposal, Delcara’s vendetta is all too real a possibility. The crew of the Enterprise along with those of the Repulse and the Chekov are stuck in the middle of the two dangerous and destructive powers in the galaxy. That’s the foundation of the story and Peter David does a good job with it but the best parts of the novel are the character interactions which isn’t a surprising to anyone who’s ever read a book by David.

There are plenty of things to like in Vendetta including the nice character moments. One of David’s strength as a Star Trek writing is that he regularly makes very interesting observation about the series as a whole or about specific episodes. A fine example of this is the conversation the characters have about nanites. In the second part of “The Best of Both Worlds”, Dr. Crusher suggests using the nanites as a weapon against the Borg. After the crew of the Enterprise defeated the Borg (by other means), this plan was proposed to Federation headquarters but the deliberation has led to a standstill because the intention of breeding a life form for the sole purpose of using them as a weapon against another life form goes against the virtues and beliefs of the United Federation of Planets. Not only does it serve as a good explanation as to why the nanite plan was never put into execution, it reminds us that the event depicted in the TV series don’t appear in a vacuum. There is more to the world of Star Trek than the bridge and the books are one of the places in which that has been explored the most.

Not all of the character moments work though, occasionally some conflict with how they’ve been portrayed before. One scene in particular Data is arguing with La Forge that they can’t recreate memories of an individual even though La Forge is convinced his ability at creating personalities in holodeck simulations. According to Data “What is created in the holodeck is not alive.” Doesn’t he remember the events in “Elementary, Dear Data” in which Moriarty, who was created in the holodeck, became self-aware? Does that not constitute a form of life by the definitions of the 24th century? Not only does his statement appear to be incorrect, it’s callous and hypocritical response from Data considering he is an artificially created life form. Maybe his assimilation among a primarily human crew has been more successful than we think.

Even though Vendetta is about a huge battle on three fronts, the characters are really at the heart of it all. David brings back a few characters form the show that we don’t get to spend a whole lot of time with. Commander Shelby returns and she’s now working as the first office of the USS Chekov under Captain Korsmo. Captain Taggert of the Repulse also returns though this time it’s Ariel Taggert, the daughter of the previous Captain Taggert, who’s taken over the command of the ship. David’s quite adept that writing these characters despite their shot appearances on screen and he also has a good time creating some pretty interesting, albeit tragic, characters with Delcara and Reannon Bonaventure.

Delcara, the woman Picard first met while studying at the Academy, is a thematic stand-in for Dulcinea, the ideal woman as depicted in Don Quixote. With their initial encounter shrouded in mystery, Picard builds her up to be the idea woman and she becomes the representation of the unknown, the undiscovered which fuelled Picard’s life to a career of space exploration and discovery. As he puts it:
“She was . . .” He paused, trying to find words.  “She was a concept. A symbol. The idea of her came to mean more to me than the actuality of her. What she represented was so pure, but the reality was far from that. In the end I tried to make her into what I envisioned her to be, and what she could never be. And yet, in a way, she is. Was. She was everything I could have asked for. Unreachable. Untouchable. Always out there, guiding me onward. I seek to touch the stars, Mr. La Forge. To brush my fingers across them, and search out the mysteries they hide. She was all of that. All of that, and more.”

Ah, as dramatic as ever, eh Picard? And as unreachable as Delcara was and will remain, it’s very unfortunate that she was a character created specifically for this novel. It strains disbelief that such an important character to Picard made her first and, very likely, her last appearance in Vendetta.

There is another Dulcinea in the story. I’m talking about Reannon Bonaventure, a woman who used to be part of the Borg Collective but was rescued by the crew of the Enterprise. During the course of the novel, Geordi La Forge develops a very strong desire to take care of Reannon and help rehabilitate her. I would say that La Forge’s behaviour is borderline obsession because it goes beyond his regularly caring nature. The rest of the crew also notice just how intense he is and question him about what his motivation is for helping Reannon. His explanation that he and Reannon are kindred spirits due to them both having a handicap isn’t very satisfying and I suspect the explanation is simply that La Forge wanted a project. He convinced himself that he could help her and he’s fixated on the idea that he can and will heal her fractured psyche. I have to say I thought Reannon’s story was interesting enough on its own without requiring the addition of whatever it was that La Forge thought was so important about helping her more than what the other characters were also doing.

Not everything in the book works. I kind of beat around the bush on how the big story is nice and David does a good job but it’s just not enough to make this a memorable story beyond the fact that the Borg face off against a newer, bigger and more powerful version of the planet-killer from “The Doomsday Machine”. Without the strong character work from David Vendetta would fall flat as a story. Thankfully, both elements balance each other nicely and it’s made a better book because of it. I was kind of surprised to see that David would even write a story on this scale as it seems to be outside of his comfort zone. Even with his comic works his stories tend to be focused on characters as opposed to huge blockbuster-end-of-the-world-or-universe stories. It also helped that David brought forth some interesting thematic elements to the book via the early scene in the holodeck where La Forge, Data, Guinan and Troi re-enact a famous scene of Don Quixote (the one where he attacks the windmill, mistaking it for a giant). It’s not a co-incidence that both Reannon and Delcara either physically look like Troi who played Dulcinea in the holodeck. Both those characters were clear stand-ins for Picard and La Forge’s personal Dulcinea. The final verdict is that Vendetta works. It’s has some flaws, certainly but David is taking the idea of a giant novel to heart and he add plenty of high-stakes action, character drama and thematic resonance to make it a memorable read. It’s just a shame that 400 pages seem a bit much because the novel does meander a bit in the beginning. I think I would have preferred he same story in less pages in order to increase the awesome-per-page ratio. But what can you do? You rarely get what you want when the Borg are around.


Sunday, 22 December 2013

Star Trek: The Next Generation: Doomsday World review


The behind-the-scenes story of Doomsday World the first collaborative Star Trek novel is more interesting than the novel itself. It was written by Carmen Carter, Peter David, Michael Jan Friedman and Robert Greenberger during TNG’s first and second seasons and while it doesn’t succeed as a good Star Trek novel, it’s nonetheless an interesting Star Trek curiosity. In the introduction written by Greenberger, he shares the story behind the writing of Doomsday World. The writers were inspired by a shared fictional universe in which many writers contribute stories and narratives with the intent of creating a larger fictional tapestry which can provide seemingly endless entertainment to readers due to the scope of the world building and the multitude of characters which all co-exist. Star Trek is a good example of a shared universe since dozens of writers have all contributed stories to several of the series both on television, film, games and novels.

Greenberger goes on to specify that they were more interesting in something akin to the Wild Cards science fiction series edited by George R. R. Martin. Wild Cards is a series of anthologies which include several stories by many writers between two covers, all of them taking place in the same shared universe. Greenberger and his friends had the idea of writing a single novel with three or four plots all of them connected and written by different authors. Although a handful of writers showed interest for the project, nothing was done for several months until Greenberger decided to write an outline. Once the outline was done, sub-plots were assigned or chosen and the writing began. Once the manuscript was completed, Friedman did a bit of a rewrite to smooth out the inconsistencies in the tone and writing styles. I have to give credit to the writers; it’s surprising that they managed to write a book that didn’t feel like it was written by four individuals. Especially considering that the segments were not as clearly defined as Greenberger’s introduction let on (you can read more about that here).

The downside of this collaborative effort, I believe, is that Carter, David, Friedman and Greenberger were too busy on trying to make their project work; they forgot to write an interesting Star Trek story. The Enterprise visit the artificial planet Kirlos to assist the Federation with an archaeological study of the planet to uncover how and why the planet was constructed. The planet is populated by the Sullurh, descendants of the Ariantu (the race that built Kirlos) and colonist from the Federation of Planets and from the K’vin Hegemony. A conspiracy plot develops and they try to frame the away team which is made up of La Forge, Data and Worf.

To everyone’s surprise, descendants of the Ariantu return to Kirlos. The Sullurh are also descendants of the Ariantu. They are the ancestors of the Ariantu that stayed on Kirlos. Over the five millennia since the creation of Kirlos, the Sullurh has progressively and intentionally changed their culture and their society to distinguish themselves from the Ariantu. They feared the arrival of the K’vin from their home world nearby would visit Kirlos and the Sullurh didn’t want to be recognized as descendants of the age-old enemies of the K’vin Hegemony. None of that really matters now since Ariantu have arrived. It’s so weird that the writers point out that the Sullurh intentionally changed their culture. You would think that 5,000 years of progress would have made them sufficiently distinguishable from the old Ariantu. Following the terrorist actions and the unexpected visit of the Ariantu, the delicate diplomatic balance of Kirlos crumbles and chaos ensues.

I have no interest in the plot what so ever. The idea of an artificial planet which was constructed to be a weapon is interesting but the story that takes place on and around Kirlos could easily have been told without the planet. The idea of a world being a weapon is poorly integrated into the story. I don’t see how the story benefitted from taking place on and around an artificial planet.

The book suffers due to a plot that is at times boring and needlessly complicated. As if that wasn't enough, the characters act nothing like they did on the TV series. Data is concerned with learning to be more authoritative after realizing that this mission is his first command of an away team. It's ridiculous. I really don't think Data would care because it doesn't help him understand the human condition in any substantial way. La Forge is similarly out of character. You would think that being the chief engineer aboard a Starfleet vessel he would be more than a little curious as to the mechanical composition of the artificial planet. Instead he plays a love sick puppy infatuated with his former archaeology professor. Speaking of archaeology, why the hell isn't Picard part of the away team? His interest in archaeology was established early on in the series and even though it's uncommon for the captain to be part of the away team, there are precedents of him doing so. The only character that doesn't act completely out of character is Worf but even he’s been better written elsewhere. 

I would qualify Doomsday World as the least favourite Star Trek novel I’ve ever read. The idea of a collaborative novel written by several writers who have experience writing Star Trek stories has quite a bit of appeal but the execution left me cold. Three of the four collaborators, David, Friedman and Greenberger, wrote another novel together: Star Trek: The Disinherited which is a TOS novel. I can only assume that Doomsday World receive a positive response during its initial release which is why another multi-writer novel exists but I really hope The Disinherited is a better book because I’ve included it on my list on my to read list because of David’s inclusion as one of the writers. At the very least it will be interesting for me to go back to a novel that takes place during TOS since I’ve spent a great deal of time watching and reading TNG in the last few months.

Wednesday, 11 December 2013

Star Trek: The Next Generation: Q-in-Law


One of the enjoyable characteristics of Star Trek literature, based on my experiences thus far, is that they have relatively simple plotlines used to create interesting character moments and provide food for thought, much like some of the better episodes of the franchise. They also generally have interesting painted covers which are always nice (though you’ll notice, there exists a patter: characters heads, with or without torso, with a ship floating in space above them). Peter David also adds an additional element to his Star Trek novels: they’re hilarious. Star Trek: The Next Generation: Q-in-Law appears to have been written primarily to provide plenty of laughs.

The plot, as stated above, is simple. Two rival merchant families of an alien race called the Tizarin are preparing for a wedding that will unify both families. They’d like to have the wedding on the Entreprise because of the diplomatic importance of the wedding. The Tizarin are organized in families and their social structure is somehow linked to the Fifth House of Betazed . . . meaning Lwaxana Troi will also be present at the wedding. For reasons unknown, Q also makes an appearance. Do you understand now why I said that Q-in-Law seems to be built around a single idea? That idea is to have Q and Lwaxana meet and give David plenty of opportunities to crack wise and make us laugh. Simply put, it’s an absolute delight.

The book isn’t about the jokes themselves, it’s just built to allow for plenty of humour. It also allows for David to write a great deal about love among other things. David does this by (you guessed it) using a couple run-on gags. One of the run-on gags is that the crew’s thoughts or infected with the idea of love because of the upcoming nuptuals. It starts with Geordi talking to one of the guys in Engineering about his rather sad love life. Geordi cheers him up but the result is that he is now depressed. This passes along through the ship like some horrible disease, travelling from a person seeking advice to the person who offers advice. It’s a surprisingly effective way for David to bring the reader up to speed on the emotional status of the crew. It can be difficult to place a tie-in novel within the chronology of the TV series it’s based on and it’s tricks like this one that not only provide context relevant to the story, but do so in an entertaining way. When it comes to TNG novels, unless you’re reading a book with Dr. Polaski or Tasha Yar in it, you could potentially be reading a story that is taking anywhere from season 3 to 7.

It’s slightly surprising just how many ridiculous situations David is able to create with the simple setup and the theme of love. My favourite has to be Wesley trying to cope with being given a Tizarin servant woman whose only concern seems to be Wesley and his sexual needs. I don’t want to go into any more detail because it’s just such a joy to read. David also writes about it while staying true to the tone of Star Trek. It’s a pretty impressive feat.

Star Trek: The Next Generation is filled with romantic couples and David takes complete advantage of that in Q-in-Law. He uses existing couples, like Troi and Riker, but also creates a few new ones such as the young Tizarin lovers Serah and Kerin. What’s most interesting is that David seems to be stating two things. One, all couples are different and two, all couples are valid whether they’re literally a couple, meaning two, or something else. Star Trek is about the exploration of alien life and David dabbles into the idea of alien love. What David writes about the couples established in TNG is limited to what’s shown on television. Picard and Crusher will never formally their affection for each other but they know it will always be there. Troi and Riker are both too focused on their careers and will never make the time to work on their relationship which is in perpetual limbo. They even talk about their relationship in a business-like way. They use their relationship as a tactical advantage in situations on the ship. The prime example is Riker’s proposal to Troi, which is made, not out of love, but out of duty. He hopes that by proposing to Troi he’ll distract Lwaxana from Q’s advances and rid the Enterprise of this strange power couple.

It’s with one of the new couples, Serah and Kerin the young Tizarins, that David writes the most interesting things about love, attractiveness and sexual desires. Q, for reasons unknown throughout most of the books, manipulates the young fiancées against each other. He sabotages the couple by having two separate conversations with them on a one-on-one basis. He uses different arguments for each youth to try and manipulate them not to get married. It’s interesting to see Q trying to understand the human concept of love. Serah and Kerin aren’t human by they seem to have an near identical idea of what an ideal romantic relationship should be. That’s the book biggest fault. Peter David missed the opportunity to write about alien love and alien relationships. Perhaps it would have been more difficult to do so while keeping a humorous tone but I’m disappointed there weren’t any attempts at writing about alien romance.

Despite a few missed opportunities, such as David not making any sex jokes with Worf (something he’s done in Star Trek novels before) Q-in-Law is a very good book. It’s constructed in such a way to provide as many romantic and sexual jokes as possible even one including Q transforming himself into an astonishingly beautiful woman just to prove a point and ruffle Picard's feature. David makes an interesting character out of Lwaxana Troi. He humanizes her by giving the reader a glimpse of her fears and doubts as a mother. It will forever affect how I see Lwaxana, not as the overbearing mother or the troublesome Betazed-Federation Ambassador. Q also has some very good moments of his own. His reason for being on the Enterprise is yet another one of his attempts to teach humanity a lesson. Of course, as it’s always the case with Q, the learning happens for all parties involved and it’s no different in Q-in-Law. I would definitively recommend this to any fan of TNG.

Wednesday, 27 November 2013

Star Trek: The Next Generation – Starfleet Academy 03: Survival


Starfleet Academy: Survival is the last book of the series written by Peter David. The Starfleet Academy series will continue for several other books leading to a total of 14 written by various Star Trek writers. The books will focus of various other characters, most notably characters of TNG during their cadet years.

Survival is a direct continuation of Line of Fire. David recaps the story of the previous book in the first few pages of Survival and continues to tell the story of how Worf and the others stayed on Dantar for two weeks. The titular survival isn’t very difficult. Several buildings of the colony where destroyed in the attack but many of them remain in a state that allowed the survivors to live in relative comfort while waiting to be rescued. 

While waiting for rescuers, the survivors spend their time fighting amongst each other. Zak and the Klingons engage in fisticuffs and tension runs high overall. Soleta finds a ship that crash landed on the planet and investigates it only to find out it’s the ship that attacked the colony. The story shifts focus and becomes about uncovering the mysteries that began in the second book. Who attacked the colony and why? The colonist who left knew they were leaving people behind, why is it that nobody has come to rescue the remaining survivors? They’re not very good mysteries because the length of the book (just above 100 pages) requires a quick resolution and David keeps the pace brisk. It’s ok though because he’s taken the time to provide more character moments than he did in the earlier stories.

I liked that even though the novel clearly focuses on Worf, David gave the rest of the Dream Team their time to shine.  Tania and Soleta are starting to feel like real characters. There is a particularly nice exchange between Tania and Worf where she expresses her discomfort and disappointment at Worf for treating her unkindly in order to impress K’Ehleyr a scene that took place earlier. Zak is given quite a lot of time in the limelight because of his dislike of Klingons but he remains a flat character. He simply repeats the events of his first encounter with Worf with other Klingon characters on Dantar. He eventually comes around and makes peace with them but he’s simply copy the same character arc from the first book. Mark also gets more scenes than in the first book but David often uses them as a way to show off his status as a genius while also using him as a source of comic relief. It’s not used excessively and has yet to be tiresome but it contributes to the third and second books feeling of being repetitive when it comes to how some of the characters act.

Part of me is glad that I’m done these books by David. Starfleet Academy sounds like a good idea but the execution doesn’t live up to the potential. Even so, I have a difficult time thinking about how these books could have been written better. There aren’t very many great stories that can be told in just over 100 pages. The style and tone of the young adult series doesn’t seem to allow for stories with much depth. I appreciate that David took the time to create a few new characters but he doesn’t have the opportunity to really develop them. As much as I really like Worf, there is too much focus on him. I completely understand why. From a publishing standpoint it’s difficult to envision that fans want to read about new characters. You expect readers to want to read something familiar, especially when considering tie-in media. I also think it’s extremely important for new characters, new series and new stories. I appreciated what David’s tried to do with his Starfleet Academy book. Now that I’m done, I’m looking forward to reading his Star Trek: New Frontier series which has many of the new characters in Starfleet Academy as regular characters in the series. It will be some time though since I’m still trying to find the first and second book of the series. In the meantime I’ll read other Star Trek books by Peter David. 

Saturday, 16 November 2013

Star Trek: The Next Generation – Starfleet Academy 02: Line of Fire

The events of the cover takes place
during the last ten pages of the book.
Don't worry, you're only about halfway
 done the story. Wait, what?

In Starfleet Academy: Line of Fire, Peter David continues to tell the story of Worf from Star Trek: The Next Generation, during his years at Starfleet Academy in San Francisco. The first novel served as an introduction to a young Worf and the friends he made at the Academy. It also focused on Worf’s first real interaction with people who didn’t accept him or trust him because of his Klingon heritage. The second novel expands on this and also adds another staple element of Worf’s character in TNG, how he seems himself not fully as a Klingon and no fully Terran, either.

We learn at the beginning of Line of Fire that Worf’s study group, comprising of Terrans Mark McHenry and Tania Tobia, Vulcan Soleta and Brikarian Zak Kebron, has become one of the Academy’s best group of students. Professors and other students have even started to call them the “Dream Team”. As such it’s not surprising that all five cadets are chosen to accompany one of their teachers on a negotiation mission on Dantar IV. Danta IV is a colony with a population that is equally divided between Terrans and Klingons. It’s a little too obvious a situation in which to spotlight Worf’s dual heritage but a direct approach isn’t always a bad thing.

The cadets travel to Dantar aboard the Repulse which we first encountered in season two, episode one of TNG. David writes a nice scenes in which Worf and Captain Taggert talk about Taggert’s crew being surprised at Worf’s appearance. Some of the crew members even do a double-take when seeing the young Klingon in a Starfleet uniform aboard their ship. Worf mentions his disappointment at the reaction of members of Starfleet. He didn’t expect shock and surprised from people who had been trained at the Academy and have likely seen many stranger things than he. Taggert’s reply is that just because you’ve gone through Starfleet training doesn’t mean you’ve been ride of the capability of being surprised. Starfleet, like many other large organizations, no matter how well organized, will always be made up of individuals who have their own beliefs and prejudices. Worf will have to learn to cope with people’s reaction to him.

It's really hot and bright on Dantar IV. It's not all bad, you get to wear
these awesome shades.

Worf gets another taste of this once they arrive on Dantar IV. So far he’s experience the reaction of his adoptive family and cadets at the Academy. He’s not in the middle of a negotiation between colonists comprised of people from both his heritage. Worf embodies nature vs. nurture, the constant struggle between his Klingon genes and his human upbringing. On Dantar his inner conflict is externalized. David also throws in a romantic interest by having K’Ehleyr be one of the Klingon negotiators. It’s so strange to me that both groups have chosen young individuals to take part and, at times, lead the negotiations.

I understand that the individuals in this novel are teens, young adults actually. They deal with everything seemingly without ease. There are scientists and other professionals in the colony but they’re unable to deal with some relatively simple tasks. I’ve always considered colonists to be strong, independent and resourceful individuals. Their job requires that they regularly deal with difficult decisions forcing them to apply problem solving skills daily. Why then are they incapable of taking care of themselves and their petty squabbles? I feel like David didn’t take the time to address this while plotting the book because of he intended audience. I also think he did this in order to avoid writing a book about the day to day lessons in Starfleet. It would probably have been a bore for David and the readers if every chapter was about the Dream Team attending class and studying.

Just like my review, the second Starfleet Academy book ends upbruptly. An unidentified ship attacks the colony and everybody evacuates except for the Dream Team, K’Ehleyr and a couple more Klingons. It’s not really a cliffhanger. The book simply ends and immediately picks up with the third book. 

Sunday, 13 October 2013

X-Factor: Visionaries Peter David volume 3 review


The third volume of ­X-Factor Visionaries: Peter David brings the focus back on the main members of the X-Factor team. It’s a big frustrating because I feel this is where the story should have picked up after the first volume. The crossover with The Incredible Hulk was a pretty major distraction even if it was a good story in itself. I enjoyed the third volume more than the second one but my enjoyment of it is hindered by the same problems I had with the previous volumes of this series.

The art inconsistencies didn’t really bother me this time around. That’s because the guest artists’ style matched up pretty closely to Larry Stroman’s art even if they did not quite reach he same level of abstraction in their line work. I don’t have much more to say about the art in these issues and that itself probably says a lot. They’re early nineties comics and it’s important to mention that because the inking and colouring have a pretty big impact on the final look of the comic. These issues look like nineties comics. The only exception would the Annual issue which is drawn by Darick Robertson and Joe Madureira. That issue looks sleeker and cleaner and it’s quite breath of fresh air but the annual they make up can best be summarized as a throwaway gag issue. It doesn’t advance the story or the characterization and the only thing it contributes to is a few laughs. Peter David has made significantly better jokes in the regular issues of X-Factor.

Thankfully the story moves along a big more in the rest of the volume. The X-Factor team deals with three mutant related issues. In one, a mutant is accused of murder and they investigate the allegations. In another story, they’re asked to protect a former member of a muscle for hire crew which offered protection to a drug cartel. The third story deals with mutant expatriates from Genosha who are travelling the seas searching for sanctuary but finding only rejection. Mutants are the Jews of the Marvel Universe it seems. All three of those stories could and for a few pages did, form the basis for interesting stories about homo sapiens and homo superior equality but they all fall short. One of the reasons of the stories do not work is that the members of X-factor always end up fighting numerous other mutants or super villains. The resolution to all these stories is a one or more superhero fights. It’s a disappointing story.

The other reason why the stories don’t seem to work is that they try to bring forward topics that would generally seem more serious in tone. Peter David is trying to pull away from the good guys fights bad guys story and steer the book into a more satisfying direction. He’s trying to offer the reader something different that also happens to have depth of story. As I mentioned, the first problem is the unnecessary requirement for superhero fisticuffs and it’s not even a particularly rewarding version of that. The second reason is that the tone of the book is in constant fluctuation form humorous to serious and thoughtful. David is unable to balance the humour and the more serious elements into a cohesive comic. This happens to be the volume which has the best humour in it. He’s done ag ood job on that fron band the best thing about the fight scenes is the banter. It’s problematic though when Havok and Val are having a serious discussion as to how to handle the mutant expatriate (or x-patriate) situation, they’Re also finding time to crack jokes.

It’s inconsistent but it has a lot of potential and it makes for a frustrating read because you keep thinking the story is going to lead to something good and worthy of thought and discussion but it often leads to bad jokes, cackling evil bad guys. The villains in this story are uninteresting and much like the stories in the Annual issue, they feel like throwaway characters that matter because of their role as villains as opposed to their importance as characters in a story. Three volumes in and it still feels like Peter David is trying to find his footing and it’s getting to be too late since he ultimately only wrote one more volume’s worth of X-Factor comics.   

Sunday, 6 October 2013

Star Trek: The Next Generation – Starfleet Academy 01: Worf’s First Adventure

Tania Tobias and Worf by Catherine Huerta.
Star Trek: The Next Generation – Starfleet Academy is a series of fourteen books that take place at the United Federation of Planet’s Starfleet Academy in San Francisco. The first three books were written by Peter David and follows the story of Worf Rozhenko’s and many other cadet’s first few months at the Academy. Worf is the first Klingon to ever be admitted to the academy and he will grow up to be one of the most beloved characters of the Star Trek: The Next Generation television series. I think it’s great that Worf is the star of these first few books because he’s one of my favourite characters for TNG but also because Peter David writes Worf really well.

My interest in these Starfleet Academy books has to do mostly with Peter David. I like his writing style and I’ve rather enjoyed the first two of his Star Trek: The Next Generation novels so I figured I’d give these a try as well. I’m also interested in reading his Star Trek: New Frontier series but I’ve read online that some characters from his previous Star Trek books appear in the series. Some of the characters that were introduced in Worf’s First Adventure are regular characters in New Frontier. It seemed like required reading before taking on David’s popular novel series.  

There are a few references to episodes of TNG. The book was published in 1993 and it mostly references events of the first three seasons of the television series. The book offers some nice backstory for Worf some of which we’ve seen before in Strike Zone and in A Rock and a Hard Place. Not all of the things David introduces remained canon. His adoptive brother’s name is a good example of information that is no longer accurate with the television series. In the book, he is named Simon but we find out in an episode of the seventh season of TNG that Worf’s brother’s name is Nikolai (which makes more sense, because Worf’s adoptive family lives in Russia).

David does a good job showing the reader why it’s important for Worf to succeed at the Academy because he’s the first Klingon to ever be admitted. There is a diplomatic importance to his success. It puts a lot of pressure on Worf and he doesn’t really have it easy in San Fran. He doesn’t really have it too difficult though. Despite his Klingon heritage he quickly made friends during the shuttlecraft ride that first brought him to the academy and he stays friends with them throughout the novel. They even formed a study group together. There is some conflict between Worf and a Brikarian but they by the end of the novel, they’ve become friends due to both being members of alien species that aren’t well represented at the Academy. Alien minorities have to stick together against the mutual threat of racial intolerance. It’s just a little strange that Worf so easily forgets that Zak Kebron, the Brikarian, is the one who antagonised Worf more than any other cadet.
 
Worf and Geordi La Forge in one of the
many pencil drawings by James Fry.
My primary complaint for this young adult novel is that it’s a young adult novel. The cadets are all in their late teens; I believe it’s mentioned that Worf is 18, so really, they’re young adults and a more mature story could easily have been told. I think the decision to market this series to young adults is a good idea but by doing so it took away some of the storytelling potential. David’s writing style doesn’t pander to younger minds, but his trademark humour is nearly absent and the more serious themes and interesting moral dilemmas of his other Star Trek novels is also absent.

A series of shorter novels designed to be sold to younger readers is an interesting idea but despite not seeing signs of intentional dumbing down of Star Trek for consumption by younger readers, there is nothing here to really spark the interest of non-Trekkies or to challenge younger minds. It’s a short book, which is fine, but it feels slight. I understand that not all young adult fiction is 500+ pages novels like Harry Potter but it doesn’t have to be 120 page novellas about going to space school where nothing really happens other than some mild bullying amongst alien cadets. I did enjoy the pencil drawings. I’d like to see that incorporated in other Star Trek novels, especially because a lot of characters and settings never had the opportunity to make it to the small screen and it would be nice to see visual representations of many of the novel-only characters.

Saturday, 28 September 2013

X-Factor: Visionaries Peter David volume 2 review


The second volume of Peter David’s tenure on X-Factor is actually half The Incredible Hulk and half X-Factor. There’s as much jade giant as there is green haired Polaris. Both series are written by Peter David and the members of X-Factor do appear in all six issues, but it made for an inconsistent read. The first two issues in the collection are The Incredible Hulk #390-391, parts one and two of a three part story. Issue #76 of X-Factor takes place afterwards and that is followed by one more issues of The Incredible Hulk and the collection ends with issues #77 and 78 of X-Factor. There’s nothing wrong about that reading order other than the fact that the Hulk issues and the story it tells completely distract from the story and the momentum David was building in the first volume.

Other than the Hulk: The End trade paperback, these are the first issues of David’s popular run on The Incredible Hulk that I’ve ever read. My first reaction is that Dale Keown’s art is excellent. It’s so good and I might have to order the first Visionaries volume of David’s hulk run just to see more of Keown’s art. Keown’s sleek and muscular art contrast pretty heavily with Stroman’s thin lines and exaggerated anatomy. Seeing Guido and Hulk on the same page is startling. Even when drawn by Keown, Guido’s musculature is so bizarre it’s truly because a part of the character. Larry Stroman only draws two of the six issues collected here and although it’s a shame because I was just getting used to his art, it is nonetheless a welcome break. I’m warming up to his style but being so closely juxtaposed with Keown, it does leave something to be desired.

I wasn’t overly impressed with the Hulk issues. The story was somewhat uninteresting but it did provide plenty of opportunity for good superhero action. That’s what the highlight was, in fact. Watching Keown’s Hulk in action was a treat and David has a much better grasp of him and his supporting cast (Rick Jones!) that he has on the characters of X-Factor. It’s difficult to judge the quality of these three issues of The Incredible Hulk since I haven’t read any of the others by the same writer and artist but I have a feeling that just like the X-Factor issues aren’t as representative of the rest of the issues written by David, the same can be said for the three-part Hulk story.

There was some good character develop in X-Factor. David is starting to get a feel for the characters and his story is developing beyond “good guys beat up bad guys” kind of stories.

I can’t finish this review without talking about the humour. It’s better than in the first volume. I think that has to do with David getting to know the characters better, he’s had the time to get accustomed to the members of the government sanctioned team of mutants. Guido especially is shaping up into an interesting character. He’s developing a voice and it’s often pretty funny. Rahne also starts to go through some changes and it’s adding some nice depth to the comic. I really like the cast of X-Factor. They’re interesting because I do not know every little thing about them and they’re not A-list characters so I know there can be and will be some serious and pretty permanent changes to their personalities and character makeup.

It’s unfortunate that The Incredible Hulk gets in the way. It’s a decent story and there are some interesting moral questions raises by some of the characters. I’m glad it was collected somewhere but I’m not sure this was the best place. I honestly can’t think of a better way to have included it. It’s right where it should be but it distracts from the real focus here which should be the X-Factor team. At the very least, Dale Keown’s art helps make the Hulk a bit more welcome in an x-book.