When I read the first volume of
Fantastic Four Visionaries: Walter Simonson I went in with some
pretty high expectations. I wasn’t quite expecting something as good as his
legendary run on
Thor but I was still
hoping to find a comic that was really worthy of the Visionaries title it was
given. I’ve read of few collections in Marvel’s Visionaries line and they’ve
all fluctuated quite a bit in quality. For the curious at home I’ve read Frank
Miller’s run on
Daredevil (excellent
stuff), Alan Davis’ more or less solo run on
Excalibur (quite good but degrades in quality with each volume),
and Peter David’s first run on
X-Factor
during the 90s (plays around with some neat ideas and is mostly memorable for
one amazing issue, the rest is basically exactly what you would expect for 90s
era X-men). In terms of quality I would place the first volume of
Fantastic Four Visionaries: Walter Simonson
between Alan Davis on
Excalibur and
Peter David on
X-Factor. It was good
but nothing exceptionally noteworthy in terms of superhero comics. The second
volume, much to my delight, is an improvement on the first.
It might help that I went into the second volume with
lower expectations but the fact is Walter Simonson impressed me a little. He
continues the story form the first volume not by giving you more, but by giving
you less. The excess and decompression of the time bubble story was the cause
of my disappointment with the first volume. With the second volume, Simonson
tells two stories related to the Fantastic Four’s adventure in the time bubble
but they’re shorter, more tightly focused stories that somehow also managed to
be very fun and enjoyable without ever being juvenile. I would also argue that
Simonson’s art is more interesting here than in the previous volume. All in
all, volume 2 which collects Fantastic
Four issues #342 to 346 suggests that Simonson’s run on Fantastic Four might just be worthy of
the Visionaries title it received. I’ll have to read the third volume to in
order to be certain.